Information Problem Reconstructed
Like many others, I read and benefited from Vivek Chibber's Class Matrix. Considering how confused contemporary sociology can become on the subject of class structure, Chibber's clarifying contributions were more than welcome. Moreover, I consider G.A. Cohen and his project an inspiration, at minimum. But significant clarifications are needed regarding Chibber's recent discussions on variants of socialism in the podcast Confronting Capitalism, published in one of the most popular radical outlets, Jacobin . Chibber, to the best of my knowledge, presents his criticisms of planned economy similarly in other popular media . He frames the planner's problem as twofold: first, an information problem; second, an incentive problem. It takes some time to wrap your head around his depiction of the information problem. Ultimately, it is indeed the standard asymmetric information problem, but tailored specifically: the planner does not know the productive capacities of individual pr...